Strange New Worlds Season 4 (Paramount+)
The 4th season of Star Trek: Strange New Worlds has completed its run, and the entire season is now available to see on Paramount+. This show, at least in my opinion, started out strong with season 1, got even better in season 2, then stumbled horribly with season 3. Season 4 is a slight improvement over the previous season, but the writers of the show still seemed hung up on doing different genres over telling good Trek stories. Here is my opinion on each episode of season 4…
Valles Marineris- The season begins with a time travel story that finds the crew 65 million years in the past. It’s not a bad one. I liked the introduction of the Martian race, the dinosaurs looked pretty good, but the idea that the Enterprise is responsible for the events that would bring about the rise of mammals and therefore humanity was a little much to dump on this story.
The Griffin Incident- I liked this one. I think we could have done the same story without shoehorning Kirk into it. Not sure why the writers need Kirk to be around so much and we are not done with him this season.
Human Best Friend- A lighter episode that has a nice Ortegas/Scotty driven A story. “Dude, Where’s My Shuttlecraft”. Not terrible.
A Case of Chiaroscuro- Here the writers decided to make a “Casablanca” story. It’s black & white, with a reason for it, and it’s fine. I will say that the fan created Star Trek: Continues did a take on a black & white world with “What Ships are For” and did it better.
Level-Five Transporter Accident- I had a love/hate relationship with this one. It has some good character moments and having Spock being the only non-puppetized crew member worked well. I might have hated it were it not to have been all in Spock’s imagination. Better than it should have been.
Off-Hour- This is their “real-time” episode. It’s not bad. I could have done without the countdown clock but is otherwise a good episode.
Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass- My least favorite of the season. First point against it was bringing back Rhys Darby’s (who I am actually a fan of. I loved Our Flag Means Death.) as Trelane, who uses the Enterprise as a school project by making the crew behave like they are in an American Soap Opera. I didn’t like the first episode he was in last season and more of him was not what I wanted. The fact that American soap operas, a dying genre today, would be in the consciousness of people in the future didn’t make sense. I felt Anson Mount’s discomfort with the dialogue. He does his best and actually delivers a nice character moment of growth before it’s over. A regular episode about Pike dealing with the loss of the lifetime he lived with his wife and child could have been great. The stunt casting of soap star Deidre Hall was fine. She was actually quite good.
Orders of Magnitude- Very similar to the TOS ep The Doomsday Machine, we have a higher-ranking office commandeering the Enterprise for his own vengeful ends. It was a very Trek feeling episode, but again, why is Kirk, who just happened to be there, the center of the A story? The B story with an away team on a planet dealing with rogue Andorians could have been an A story. I liked it, but again, why Kirk again?
Once Upon La’an a Time- This one is kind of a sequel to a season 1 ep that was just “ok” and is fine. There is a lot of “just because” explanations for the events that unfold but is otherwise not as bad as it could have been. We’re also left wondering if Carol Kane’s Pelia was written out, or if she’ll be back. Kirk is in this one too.
Tomorrow’s Enterprise- A sort-a-kind-a time travel ep. Bookending the season I suppose. This is an Uhura episode and gave them an excuse for dressing Celia Rosee Gooding and Jess Bush’s Chapel their TOS uniforms and hairstyles and of course an excuse to use Kirk again, as Captain of the future Enterprise. It made sense and would have been nicer to see if he hadn’t been overly included in so many previous eps this season. There were background appearances by some ‘70’s animated series aliens, including M’Ress, the Cat-Woman. That was fun, but it took me out of the episode for a moment.
While an improvement over season 3 they still came off as more “off track” than on, for me. There have been plenty of mediocre to just bad episodes of other Trek shows, but in those cases they had around 24 episodes per season to fill. When we are only presented with 10 per season and they make 5 mediocre to bad eps that’s half of the season. The two big swing episodes of season 2 were a couple of their best. Each time they tried to do it again, mostly, hurt the show. At least in my opinion. Because of that they now have to really stick the landing with their shortened season 5. I always hope for the best and will be there when it’s released.
Create Your Own Website With Webador